New Sheffield Cafe Menu
Welcome to New Sheffield Cafe, a culinary gem located at 3154 Brodhead Rd, Aliquippa, PA. This cafe delights patrons with a robust menu featuring oversized portions and a warm atmosphere. Renowned for its scrumptious breakfast offerings, many guests rave about the beer selection and attentive service.
- Hearty Soups: Try the flavorful chili for just $4.95, packed with satisfying spices.
- Delicious Burgers: Featured are the mouthwatering mushroom and Swiss burgers, complemented by crispy deep-fried hot pepper rings.
- Breakfast Scramblers: Highly recommended, these dishes are a favorite among regulars.
- Desserts: Don’t forget to peek at the tempting cakes displayed as you enter!
With a focus on quality and value, New Sheffield Cafe is a must-visit for anyone seeking great food and a friendly atmosphere.
Starters
Sides
Soup
Salads
Wings
Sandwiches
Baskets & Wraps
Kiddie Menu
Cafe Favorites
Cafe Kabobs
Cafe Mixes
Pasta
Desserts
Extras - Veggies
Extras - Meat
Extras - Bread and Pasta
Extras - Cheese
Extras - Sauces and Dressings
Extras - Dip
Beverages
Starters
Hot Cheese Balls
$8.50
Fried Banana Pepper Rings
$9.25
Provolone Sticks
$7.95
Zucchini Planks
$9.25
Fried Mushrooms
$8.95
Fried Pickles
$8.95
Fried Shrimp App
$9.95
Coconut Shrimp App
$9.95
Potato Skins
$9.25
Munchie Platter
$15.95
Nachos w/Cheese
$8.45
Nachos Supreme w/Chicken
$15.95
Nachos Supreme w/Beef
$15.95
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
$11.95
Buffalo Chicken Dip
$11.95
Stuffed Hot Banana Peppers
$12.45
Steak Quesadilla
$12.95
Chicken Quesadilla
$11.95
Shrimp Quesadilla
$13.95
Cheese Quesadilla
$9.95
Veggie Quesadilla
$10.95
Basket of Breadsticks
$7.95
Bavarian Pretzel Sticks
$11.95
Basket of Quip Chips
$7.75
Basket of Fries
$6.25
Basket of Onion Rings
$8.95
Basket of Sweet Potato Fries
$7.95
Basket of Waffle Fries
$7.25
Side of Fries
$3.95
Side of Quip Chips
$3.95
Side of Onion Rings
$3.95
Side of Fried Banana Pepper Rings
$3.95
Side of Waffle Fries
$3.95
Side of Sweet Potato Fries
$3.95
Side of Mac & Cheese
$3.95
Bowl of Mac & Cheese
$4.95
Side of Cole Slaw
$1.80
Side of Mashed Potatoes
$3.25
Sides
Soup
Chili - Take Out Bowl
$4.95
Steak Salad
Chicken Salad
Nugget Salad
Chicken & Steak Salad
Fish Salad
Gyro Salad
Caesar Salad
Chef Salad
Grilled Shrimp Salad
Taco Salad
Tossed Salad
Salads
Wings
Whole Wings
Wingers (12)
$17.25
Boneless Wings
Hot Roast Beef Sandwich
$13.95
Hot Turkey Sandwich
$12.95
Hot Hamburger
$11.95
Gyro
$8.95
Italian Hoagie
$10.95
Philly Steak Hoagie
$10.95
Chicken Philly Hoagie
$10.95
Meatball Hoagie
$10.45
Hot Sausage Sandwich
$8.95
Reuben Sandwich
$11.95
Triple Decker
$12.45
Turkey Bacon Club
$12.45
Fish Sandwich
$12.95
Tuna Melt
$8.95
Grilled Cheese
$6.95
BLT
$8.95
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$8.95
Build-A-Burger
$10.95
Sandwiches
Baskets & Wraps
Chicken Tenders & Fries Basket
$12.95
Fish Basket
$12.95
Shrimp Basket
$13.95
Coconut Shrimp Basket
$14.95
Grilled Chicken Wrap
$10.95
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
$10.95
Burger Wrap
$10.95
KIDS Cheeseburger Sliders (2) & Fries
$6.95
KIDS Chicken Nuggets & Fries
$6.95
KIDS Fish Nuggets & Fries
$6.95
KIDS Grilled Cheese & Fries
$5.95
KIDS Linguine & Meatball
$5.95
Kiddie Menu
Cafe Favorites
Steak N' Noodles
$15.95
Bret's Special
$17.25
Chicken Naturelle
$15.45
Lamb Kabob
$15.95
Beef Kabob
$15.95
Lamb & Beef Kabob
$16.95
Chicken Kabob
$14.45
Shrimp Kabob
$15.95
Cafe Kabobs
Cafe Mixes
Steak Mixer
$15.45
Chicken Mixer
$13.95
Nugget Mixer
$11.95
Steak & Chicken Mixer
$15.45
Steak & Nugget Mixer
$13.45
Gyro Mixer
$10.95
Fettuccine Alfredo
$12.95
Linguine & Meatball
$11.95
Penne Ala Vodka
$12.95
Pasta
Desserts
Bananas Foster Pie
$8.45
Butter Pecan Cheesecake
$6.95
Carrot Cake
$8.45
Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
$8.95
Chocolate Chip Cookie Milk Cake
$8.95
Colossal Chocolate Mousse Cake
$8.45
Chocolate Ganache Cheesecake
$8.45
Chocolate Marshmallow Cookie Dough Cake
$9.45
Cinnamon Roll Cheesecake
$8.45
Coconut Cloud Cake
$8.95
German Chocolate Cake
$7.45
Gingerbread Cake
$7.95
Italian Lemon Creme Cake
$7.45
Limoncello Cake
$6.45
New York Colossal Cheesecake
$8.45
Peanut Butter Pie
$8.45
Red Velvet Cake
$9.45
Salted Carmel Brownie w/Pretzel Crust
$5.45
Snickers Pie
$8.45
Summerberry Stack Cake
$7.45
Side of Lettuce
$1.79
Side of Egg
$1.79
Side of Fried Egg
$1.79
Side of Onion
$1.79
Side of Olive
$1.79
Side of Tomato
$1.79
Side of Peppercini
$1.79
Side of Mushrooms
$1.79
Side of Grilled Mushrooms
$1.79
Side of Grilled Onions
$1.79
Side of Red Peppers
$1.79
Side of Roasted Red Peppers
$1.79
Side of Jalapenos
$1.79
Side of Green Beans
$2.39
Side of Avocado
$2.39
Side of Celery
$1.79
Side of Pickles
$1.79
Extras - Veggies
Extras - Meat
Side of Steak
$5.99
Side of Chicken
$5.99
Side of Chicken Nuggets
$5.99
Side of Shrimp
$6.99
Side of Gyro Meat
$5.99
Side of Fish
$5.99
Side of Bacon
$2.95
Side of Meatballs
$5.99
Side of Beef (Kabob)
$5.99
Side of Lamb
$5.99
Side of Burger Meat
$5.99
Side of Roast Beef
$5.99
Side of Turkey
$5.99
Side of Corned Beef
$4.99
Breadstick
$1.29
Side of Croutons
$0.99
Side of Rice Pilaf
$3.15
Side of Hush Puppies
$3.15
Side of Tortilla Chips
$3.15
Side of Bread Bites
$2.95
Side of Pita
$1.39
Extras - Bread and Pasta
Extras - Cheese
Side of Cubed Cheese
$1.39
Side of Shredded Cheese
$1.39
Side of Cubed and Shredded Cheese
$1.39
Side of Shredded Cheddar
$1.39
Side of Shredded Mix
$1.39
Side of Feta
$1.99
Side of Shaved Parmesan
$1.49
Side of Parmesan Cheese
$1.39
Side of American Cheese
$1.39
Side of Provolone Cheese
$1.39
Side of Cheddar Cheese
$1.39
Side of Pepper Jack Cheese
$1.39
Side of Swiss Cheese
$1.39
Side of Nacho Cheese
$1.39
Side of Beer Cheese
$1.39
Side of BBQ
$1.39
Side of Honey BBQ
$1.39
Side of Carolina Tangy BBQ
$1.39
Side of Hot
$1.39
Side of Honey Garlic Stinger
$1.39
Side of Sweet Teriyaki
$1.39
Side of Candy Pepper
$1.39
Side of Butter Garlic
$1.39
Side of Garlic Parmesan
$1.39
Side of Buffalo Bleu
$1.39
Side of Pineapple Habanero
$1.39
Side of Seasoned
$1.39
Side of Cajun
$1.39
Side of Deli BBQ
$1.39
Side of Ranch
$1.39
Side of Sweet & Sour
$1.39
Side of 1000 Island
$1.39
Side of Bleu Cheese
$1.39
Side of Italian
$1.39
Side of French
$1.39
Side of Balsamic
$1.39
Side of Oil and Vinegar
$1.39
Side of Honey Mustard
$1.39
Side of Caesar
$1.39
Side of Dill
$1.39
Side of Mayo
Side of Ketchup
Side of Mustard
Side of Brown Gravy
$1.39
Side of Turkey Gravy
$1.39
Side of Yum Yum Sauce
$1.39
Side of Horsey
$1.39
Side of Cocktail
$0.59
Side of Pina Colada
$1.39
Side of Tartar
$0.59
Side of Salsa
$1.39
Side of Sour Cream
$1.39
Side of Marinara Sauce
$1.39
Side of Alfredo Sauce
$1.39
Side of Vodka Sauce
$1.39
Extras - Sauces and Dressings
Extras - Dip
Side of Spinach Artichoke Dip
$4.49
Pepsi
$2.00
Diet Pepsi
$2.00
Mountain Dew
$2.00
Ginger Ale
$2.00
Root Beer
$2.00
Sunkist Orange
$2.00
Starry
$2.00
Brisk Iced Tea
$2.00
Water
$1.00